Michigan Supreme Court Preserves Important Public Act 233 Rights for All Affected Local Governments
Court leaves in place ruling that counties and other local units without zoning jurisdiction are affected local units
LANSING, Mich. – The Michigan Supreme Court has left intact a significant Court of Appeals victory for local governments affected by utility-scale renewable energy projects under Public Act 233 of 2023.
Foster Swift Collins & Smith, PC represented a coalition of townships and counties challenging the Michigan Public Service Commission’s October 10, 2024 order implementing PA 233. The Commission had interpreted the term “affected local unit,” or “ALU,” to include only local governments exercising zoning jurisdiction over a proposed project.
The Court of Appeals rejected that interpretation. In its May 7, 2026 published opinion, the Court held that PA 233 provides a purely geographic definition: a county, township, city, or village is an ALU if all or part of a proposed energy facility will be located within its boundaries. A local government does not need to exercise zoning jurisdiction to qualify. The Court concluded that the Commission’s narrower definition effectively rewrote the statute and could not stand.
On November 20, 2026, the Supreme Court declined to review that portion of the Court of Appeals’ decision. As a result, the Court of Appeals’ ruling on ALUs remains in place.
“This is an important win for counties and other local governments that may not exercise zoning authority over a project site but will nevertheless experience the project’s impacts,” said Michael D. Homier, leader of Foster Swift’s Municipal Practice Group. “The decision confirms that those communities cannot be excluded from the rights and protections the Legislature provided under PA 233 simply because another local government exercises zoning jurisdiction.”
Under the Court of Appeals’ decision, all geographically affected local governments are entitled to the benefits and participation rights PA 233 provides to ALUs. Those include notice of public meetings, the opportunity to review and comment on proposed projects, the right to intervene in Commission contested cases, potential grant funding to support participation in those proceedings, and host community agreements requiring payment of $2,000 per megawatt of nameplate capacity located within the ALU for police, fire, public safety, infrastructure, or other agreed projects.
The Supreme Court also denied the local governments’ application for leave to appeal the portions of the Court of Appeals’ decision that upheld other aspects of the Commission’s order. Those issues included the Commission’s interpretation of compatible renewable energy ordinances, its treatment of hybrid energy facilities, and whether the order should have been adopted through formal rulemaking. Although we are disappointed that the Court declined to take up those issues, the ALU ruling preserves meaningful statutory rights for every community in which a qualifying energy facility is proposed.
The Supreme Court separately granted oral argument on limited issues raised by the Commission and the industry intervenors in their cross-appeals. Those issues concern the Court of Appeals’ holding, also favorable to local governments, that the 30-day period for a chief elected official to notify a developer that the ALU has a compatible renewable energy ordinance begins after the meeting with the developer, not after receipt of the developer’s offer to meet. The Court will hear arguments during its January 2027 session. The cross-appeals do not disturb the Court of Appeals’ holding that ALU status is based on the location of the project, not zoning jurisdiction.
Foster Swift will continue to represent local governments in the Supreme Court proceedings and in matters arising under PA 233 before the Michigan Public Service Commission.
About Foster Swift
Foster Swift Collins & Smith, PC assists townships, cities, villages, counties, authorities, and other public bodies throughout Michigan. The firm’s municipal attorneys advise local governments on zoning and land use, utility-scale renewable energy projects, public infrastructure, governance, litigation, and regulatory proceedings.